Book Review: “A Long Petal of the Sea,” by Isabel Allende

Spaniards were long kept in the dark about their complicated history: first, because Franco’s one-sided version was the only one taught until after he died in 1975. After that, as part of Spain’s transition to democracy, the government enacted a “pact of forgetting,” hoping it would help the country move on from its painful past.

But deep within those who lived through the Spanish Civil War was an anguished and certain knowledge that could not be extinguished.  In the last decade or two, authors, filmmakers, academics and others began to show a way forward, Isabel Allende among them.

A Long Petal of the Sea by Isabel Allende. Random House, New York, 2020

Allende has a deeply personal connection with this saga of war, fascism and democracy which begins in Spain and ends in her Chilean homeland. Among other things, her uncle was Salvador Allende whose government was toppled by Chile’s military coup.

If you come to this book expecting historical fiction that aligns closely with real life, you will be amply rewarded. The main character is Valencian, Victor Dalmau, who is studying medicine in Barcelona when war breaks out. He is not yet a doctor but when the military coup erupts he is thrown into the maelstrom.

The first chapter takes place towards the end of the three-year war when the Republican Army, having run out of older men, is reduced to conscripting fifteen and sixteen year old boys — the “baby bottle generation.”

Victor comes across a horrifically injured young soldier whose exposed heart has stopped and is expected to die. In a spur of the moment, even inspired, decision, Victor massages the stilled heart. Miraculously, it resumes beating and the boy goes on to survive.

This stilled-then-beating heart is an apt metaphor for Allende’s story of Victor Dalmau and his family: his brother Guillem (killed in the war), his mother Carme, and a young woman named Roser who was pregnant with Guillem’s child; though it’s not until the book ends that the heart beats strong and true.

As Franco achieves victory in early 1939, the three Dalmau family survivors escape over the Pyrenees into the wretched refugee camps on the fenced beaches of France. There, acclaimed Chilean poet, Pablo Neruda, arranges for a boat to bring two thousand of the Spanish refugees to his homeland, among them Victor and Roser who by now has had her baby.

I often felt I was reading an absorbing true story, so wasn’t surprised when Allende wrote in her acknowledgements, “This is a novel, but the events and historical characters are real. The characters are fictional, inspired by people I’ve known. I have had to imagine very little, because as I was doing the exhaustive research…I found I had more than enough material. This book wrote itself, as if it had been dictated to me.”

The only quibble I have is with the title. I know why it was chosen—it is Pablo Neruda’s poetic description of Chile and is Allende’s way of paying tribute—but it initially led my expectations astray and having read other reviews, I suspect I wasn’t the only one.

Five stars for an epic historical novel that strengthens Spain’s heartbeat.

A Long Petal of the Sea by Isabel Allende. Random House, New York, 2020

Reviewed by Janette Higgins, July 2021

***

This blog is about Fighting for Democracy by Jim Higgins, the latest book about the Mac-Paps, Canadians in the Mackenzie Papineau Battalion, which was part of the International Brigades in the Spanish Civil War.

Jim Higgins' book, Fighting for Democracy, along with other books about Canadians in the Sp;anish Civil War.

Order book Here

Order eBook Kobo Store, Nook Store, Amazon Kindle Store, Apple Books, Google Play, Friesen Press (all formats)

Other books about Canadians in the Spanish Civil War include Not For King or Country by Tyler Wentzell Mac-Pap by Ronald Liversedge with David Yorke and Renegades by Michael Petrou. My mini reviews here.

6 thoughts on “Book Review: “A Long Petal of the Sea,” by Isabel Allende

  1. Juan Jose Ibanez

    Sounds simply fantastic, Janette. Thanks for such a lovely book review. I have read about this story and I had the chance to meet some people whose parents reached Chili on the Winnipeg when I lived in Santiago between Nov. 1990 & March 1992. This will be a great reading for my summer holiday!
    Another interesting and pretty unknown story is the one of the Stanbrook, the British vessel that evaciayed 3,000 Republicans from Alicante to Oran (Algeria) just 3 days before the war ended.
    Keep in touch. Have a great summer!

    1. Janette Higgins Post author

      How interesting that you met people whose parents were on the boat, Juan Jose. Get ready to enjoy! I read it very quickly. Such a good story.

      I think I’ve heard someone mention the Stanbrook in one of the Spanish Civil War groups I belong to on Facebook, but I didn’t know about getting refugees out of Alicante. Thanks for that new piece of info.

      Speaking of groups on Facebook, I think there are a couple you would be interested in belonging to. I’ll send you an invitation and you can decide.

  2. Wilf Day

    I feel amply rewarded merely by reading this gripping review. I will try to read this book after the dozen other books on my reading list.

    1. Janette Higgins Post author

      There are others I can recommend as well! 🙂
      I do understand about the pile of books. I have a friend like that. He just bought five yesterday and still has several unread at home.

  3. Susan Higgins

    Someone a few months ago mentioned “Long Petal” to me and recommended it. (I came across the title scrawled on a piece of paper amongst the disorder on my desk recently…)
    Your review is motivation to read it! A very engaging review. Thanks.

    1. Janette Higgins Post author

      There are several books I’ve read that have rounded out the picture for me. I’m loving the enthusiastic feedback from people here so maybe I’ll review a few more. I’m especially interested in the writers, journalists and photographers who were over there.There’s also a new book out that isn’t available in North America yet. The author is David Ebsworth, who’s written a number of books with interesting angles on the Spanish Civil War theme.

      By the way, the last time I watched Casablanca, it didn’t twig that there is a Spanish Civil War connection. If Peter can get a hold of it I’d love to see it next week when I’m at your place. That is, if you two would be interested in watching it for probably the umpteenth time!

Comments are closed.